In "The Metamorphosis," Franz Kafka writes of a man, Gregor Samsa, who wakes up one morning transformed into an insect. Shocked of his transformation, Gregor goes back to sleep thinking he will wake up and everything will be back to normal. Instead, he wakes up late for work and still an insect. Worried about Gregor, his family calls for him to get out of bed. Gregor's response sounds far from human, causing them to call for a doctor. When his family finally sees him, they don't know how to react. His mother looks away, and his father aggressively pushes Gregor back into his room. Grete, Gregor's sister, was the only one who even attempted to help. She brought him food and water twice a day, while their parents stayed away.
Since Gregor was the only one in the family that had a job before his "metamorphosis," his father had to get a job for the first time in five years. His parents went on in life as if Gregor had died. Two weeks after his change, his mother finally gets the courage to enter Gregor's room to help Grete move his furniture. Once she sees him, she faints. When his father comes home, and hears about what has happened, he immediately goes after Gregor while throwing apples at him. After finally injuring Gregor with an apple, his mother begged his father to spare his life.
Gregor's parents kept him in his room so no one would know that he'd been transformed. When their cook quit, she promised not to tell anyone of the situation. The uniqueness of their situation kept them from asking for help. Grete and her mother felt sympathy for Gregor, trying to make him feel as comfortable as possible by moving his furniture so he could crawl around until he turned back into a human. However, his father felt that Gregor's transformation meant trouble and that he should be destroyed. They did not question why the transformation happened, or how. They acted as if it never happened and went on with life without him.
Gregor turned into an insect because his life was like an insect's. Not only did he only live to work, he had no social life with anyone in his family. Both his mother and sister showed some affection for Gregor after his metamorphosis, but his father showed absolutely none. Gregor actually talked to his sister before his metamorphosis and had dreams of her becoming a violinist. His mother obviously had the motherly instinct of loving and protecting her son, or what used to be her son. Gregor's relationship with his father never had any love or affection. His father only saw Gregor as money, not as a son.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Wow...it seems that you're the only one who did this blog assignment so far; I guess I'll comment on your blog again, so that I won't forget to post a comment for this week's special blog.
ReplyDeleteFirst of all, this blog reads like a summary of the story. Instead of just saying: "they did not question why the transformation happened, or how" and "they acted as if it never happened and went on with life without him", try explaining why this is so. Why did the family pretend nothing happened? Were they ashamed? Shocked? To what extend were they trying to come to terms with what happened? Why did they move on with life without Gregor? What is it about the transformation that changed the attitude of the family towards Gregor?
You also mentioned that Gregor's father felt that the transformation meant trouble and that Gregor should be destroyed. The question you should think about is: why would the transformation be trouble? How could a father destroy his son, just because of such 'transformation'? Is Gregor not his son anymore, just because he no longer looked human? What does this tell us about Gregor's father?
You should move to a deeper level of analysis and give some thoughts about the significance of the story as a whole (not just the content of the story, but what is the author trying to tell us with his writing? Franz Kafka most likely didn't just write a story about a man turning into a giant bug just because he felt like it...)
I agree with Myra that you have only summarized the story. You need more analysis of characterization and the narration. You need to write more about the narrative structure and imagery. Myra mentioned this already, but you need to talk about the significance of the story as a whole and the message of the author.
ReplyDeleteYou mentioned that "Gregor was the only one in the family that had a job before his 'metamorphosis,'" which I think could be elaborated on more to answer the prompt. Perhaps the family is poor (or middle class) and is not educated enough to find such a change shocking - it is mentioned at one point that his mother has not received much of an education. Also, towards the end of your blog, you describe the different reactions between the sexes. Could Kafka be making a statement about the differences between men and women?
ReplyDeleteFor your blog this week, I felt like you did just summarize the story but at the same time that is what you were asked to do. To take it a step further I think you need to analyze the story and go into further detail about how and why the family reacts as they do. Is there some kind of hidden message behind his transformation as a bug? After reading it again right now, I see that you did analyze the mothers reaction in terms of when she moved the furniture. You mentioned that she was sympathetic toward her son, showing us how she felt. My only comment is that the question WHY these things happen needs to be addressed.
ReplyDeleteI'm going to have to agree with everyone else who left a comment that you have summarized what happened and there isn't enough analysis. Each characters reaction are extremely different and need more analysis to explain why they react that way. It is evident that his sister shows little care for her brother by leaving him food and it's more care than what the mother and father give. However none of them question his change because none of them care about Gregor a person. Instead of thinking about their son and brother being a bug they think about themselves and that's because like them Gregor does the same. He doesn't think about himself, he thinks about his family and his job over himself. He doesn't even care to question his bug transformation, why should his family. He becomes a bug because Kafka is showing the world Gregor's worth in society. Because Gregor lives his life like a mindless insect and does nothing but eats, sleeps, and works, he becomes one.
ReplyDeleteI think you summarized the story and you didn't give much analysis on what was asked. You did however answer the reactions the families had towards his transformation. You should improve your blog by adding more analysis to it and try to answer the second part of the blog on why Kafka transformed him into a giant bug and for what purpose. This blog entry was probably a bit confusing but i think you should try to improve it and follow the comments your peers gave you to make this blog better.
ReplyDeleteGretchen,
ReplyDeleteFor your special blog overall I believe that you had a wonderful depiction of the summary. You go into good details that initially set up the reader to understanding the story. One thing that I think is lacking is analysis. Like mentioned by other people, you are missing the deeper connection. I think that your summary can be connected with a well developed analysis. Everyone has a different perspective on certain ideas and it would have be nice to hear your response. Usually other people catch different interpretations that may not be seen by others. A positive aspect that could have been added deals with why Gregor turned into a bug. I would love to hear from you why you personally believe Gregor was transformed into a giant bug.
I belive that most people have already mentioned that you mainly summarized the story. However, in the summary, you were able to hit points essential to the core of the story. One comment that really triggered a response from me was "Gregor turned into an insect because his life was like an insect's". It is funny to say, and a great oversight on my part, but I never really thought about "why an insect?". Your comment made me think of the insects that only live for the purpose of working or reproducing, doing their part for the cycle of life, but nothing more. Only humans go beyond that cycle, but with Gregor's lifestyle of going from one place to another and only working, his life was no different than that of an insect. Therefore, it makes perfect sense for him to turn into a giant bug, because that is what he is.
ReplyDeleteYou did a really good job on summarizing the story and on some aspects you did mention a few main points of the story but you need to dig deeper into your analysis. You could have analyzed the story a bit more so that the readers have a better comprehension of the story.
ReplyDeleteIt's true that most of the blog is a summary but there is vague anyaylsis that made me better understand what the family meant to gregor. Like you said "Gregor turned into an insect because his life was like an insect's. Not only did he only live to work, he had no social life with anyone in his family." Your right, after gregor transformed his family seem to not care at all about him, or even befor his transformation for that matter. It seemed like they only kept him around was because he was supporting the family financially and when he coudln't do that, he became more of a chore to deal with then helpful. But your summarization of the story is spot on.
ReplyDeleteFirst of all, as all other people's comments, for your blog, it shows that you had done a good job on close reading the story. You clarified some of the story plot which helped me a lot in understanding this story. However, I agree that you should expand your analysis more than just observation of the reading. Try to explain more about Kafka's intention: what does he wants to reveal by evolving a man to a bug?
ReplyDeleteWhile you did an excellent job summarizing the story, I could not really pick out your feelings on the ideas in the story. Although your last paragraph does provide some insight as to why Gregor was transformed into an insect, you have not said to much about why Gregor's family never questions his turning into an insect. As I said before, this is a good summary, but it needs more analysis.
ReplyDelete